Saturday, February 26, 2005
When it rains, sewage pours
Old infrastructure allows slime to seep into artists' home, studio
By Dan Shapley
George Mansfield and Kazumi Tanaka stand by the basement
wall in their Beacon home that seeped sewage during a heavy rainstorm in
Mansfield and Tanaka live at 5 Spring Valley St. in
Realtors told George Mansfield and Kazumi Tanaka they were the
kind of people Beacon wanted -- sculptors from New York who have since
transformed a rundown brick apartment building into a stylish flat and rental
For five years, having a small community of artists and easy
access to jobs in New York have made Beacon a good fit for the Brooklynites.
Except, that is, when it rains.
Heavy rains make sewage from the city's century-old pipes bubble
out of nearby manholes, flowing into the street, nearby yards and the Fishkill
Creek that flows past their home and winds to the Hudson River.
In January, sewage poured through the walls and flowed knee-deep
into their basement and an addition that is a few months from becoming the
couple's studio. It flowed out of drains into their tenant's first-floor
apartment. They have spent $1,000 already, and estimate it could cost another
$3,000 to finish cleaning up -- all of which they expect the city to reimburse.
''We were blessed to get this place," Mansfield said. ''Now,
we're fighting to keep it from being washed away.''
Why old sewers don't work Old sewers fail because storm water
gets into pipes designed to carry only waste.
During heavy rains, storm water enters the sewer via storm
drains or illegal hookups, such as when sump pumps are used to empty out flooded
This water overwhelms the system, and pressure builds in the
pipes until the water finds an outlet.
Sewage can bubble out of man hole covers and into streets, yards
or nearby streams. In some cases, the sewage can also back up through pipes and
into people's homes.
In 1981, the federal government recognized problems like these
were only going to grow more common in older communities as sewage systems age.
Similar problems have occurred in New Paltz, Poughkeepsie, Kingston and
elsewhere in recent years. With an amendment to the Clean Water Act, Congress
set up the State Water Pollution Control Revolving Fund to give communities low-
interest loans to upgrade their sewage systems.
In January, President Bush proposed cutting the budget for the
program by a third -- from $1.09 billion to $730 million. Last year, the budget
was cut by $250 million.
The proposed cut comes only months after the EPA identified a
national need for between $331 billion and $450 billion over 20 years to upgrade
the nation's sewage infrastructure.
Sewage flowing into basements is an obvious problem. Sewage
flowing into streams can also increase the chance of waterborne illness for
swimmers, anglers and kids who play in the water. It can poison aquatic life.
Outdated sewage systems also affect business, said Michael Di
Tullo, president of Mid Hudson Pattern for Progress, a regional planning group.
Good central water and sewer systems attract business to established cities and
villages, where environmentalists and planners agree new development should take
place. Without good infrastructure in cities, open land in the countryside is
more attractive, he said.
''From a business perspective, and this is very much related to
the environment, there is no way you can have smart growth -- that is, growth
directed into high density areas -- without infrastructure,'' DiTullo said.
''Without resources, we will continue to see sprawl, we will continue to see
development out in the rural areas where land is cheaper, and not around
Payouts less than requested
A study by Mid-Hudson Pattern for Progress revealed in 2004,
communities in six Hudson Valley counties requested $903.2 million more than was
paid out by the federal revolving fund loan program, which is administered by
the state Environmental Facilities Corporation. Total requests exceeded $1
billion, and only 12 percent of funding requests were granted in 2004, according
to the report.
''We think the federal government is going in the wrong
direction with this,'' DiTullo said.
Environmental groups and a coalition of municipal sewage plant
operators also decried the cuts. The Association of Metropolitan Sewerage
Agencies has urged Congress not only to restore the proposed cuts, but also to
set up a trust fund for sewage infrastructure projects.
Two local officials facing significant sewer upgrade projects
said the loan program is not generous enough to be critical to their work.
Beacon plans to apply for one of the loans to help it pay for
upgrades to its sewage system that should correct the overflows near Mansfield
and Tanaka's home. Now, storm drains are connected to the sewer, allowing water
to overwhelm the system and cause overflows during rain storms. The project will
separate the rain water and sewage pipes.
Over 20 years, the loan could save 1 percent of the $1.7 million
cost of the project, City Administrator Joe Braun estimated. While helpful, that
isn't enough to affect the city's decision to take on this, or any other
project, Braun said.
''If it's worth doing, we would do it in any case,'' he said.
This year, the Village of Fishkill plans to rebuild and increase
the capacity of the sewer treatment plant it built more than 30 years ago. It
has saved about half the total cost -- between $2 million and $3 million -- and
will apply for grants, take out bonds or apply for low-interest loans to cover
Low interest rates help
The loan program is not as attractive an option now, given that
interest rates are so low, Mayor James Miccio said. And the loans aren't the
''There are grants still out there, even with the budget cuts,''
Miccio said. ''There's still a lot of money out there to be had.''
Environmental groups are concerned not only about the proposed
budget cut, but an EPA proposal to allow sewage treatment plants to blend and
discharge untreated sewage with treated sewage during heavy rains. This practice
already happens, but environmental groups say instead of sanctioning it, the EPA
should require plants to upgrade.
On the Hudson River, environmental groups say the lack of
funding and the blending rule could make it more difficult to reach Gov. George
Pataki's goal of making the entire Hudson River safe for swimming by 2009 -- the
400th anniversary of explorer Henry Hudson's voyage up the river.
Sewage poses health risk
''Certainly it's diluted, but raw sewage even in a diluted form
poses a public health and environmental risk,'' said Rich Schiafo, a project
manager for Poughkeepsie-based Scenic Hudson. ''Just because it's happening now,
it's not appropriate to stamp it as OK. We should recognize it is happening now,
but provide the appropriate funding to take care of the problem.''
For Mansfield and Tanaka, the immediate concern is preventing
sewage from ruining their investment and quality of life. But the role of
federal government spending on the project goes beyond the stink of sewage and
to the heart of the community they live in.
The city has acknowledged problems like the ones Mansfield and
Tanaka have seen are present throughout the city, and that it will take many
years and dollars to fix them all. Mansfield and Tanaka don't want to see the
burden of those fixes fall solely on local taxpayers at a time when new
development and wealth is already transforming the community.
In the five years Mansfield and Tanaka have lived in Beacon,
prices have jumped so much that their other artist friends have been priced out,
and they've seen longtime residents squeezed as well.
''I don't think people should be forced out because they can't
afford to live here,'' Mansfield said.
Dan Shapley can be reached at
Sewage spurs deadly cycle
1 -- Too much food: High nutrient inputs, via sewage or
agricultural practices, are dumped into the river.
2 -- New growth Phytoplankton, which is made up of algae,
bacteria and other microscopic plant-like life, feed off these nutrients and
grow excessively throughout the river.
3 -- Beneath a blanket: The surface becomes blanketed, leaving
underwater plants in the dark. Once an important source of dissolved oxygen,
these underwater plants die off.
4 Lack of oxygen: When plankton mats decompose in the fall, they
consume what little aquatic oxygen is left beneath them, making the water
inhospitable for fish.